Delkin Blog

The Effects of Radiation on NAND Flash Based Devices



 This article describes the effects of radiation on NAND FLASH devices and covers possible ways to minimize such effects.


Applications Involving Radiation Exposure

Most consumer-based products are not usually exposed to radiation. Even through security screening devices, levels are very low. However, it wouldn’t be recommended to put them

through a full-fledged X-Ray or CT Scan. Years ago, EEPROMS, heavily used in embedded systems, with the ultra-violet erase window, could not pass through security checks at the airport, at the risk of losing data. As one can imagine this caused all sorts of use limitations and transport issues. We have come a long way since then, but we still are not totally invulnerable.

Devices used in Aerospace, Aircraft and medical applications are some examples of cases where one must consider radiation effects on electronic devices.


Products Requiring Radiation Effect Considerations

Increasing demand for higher memory densities in space and aircraft electronics has generated significant interest in the use of flash NAND based devices. However, there are a number of features of NAND flash memory that require additional care when they are used in these applications. In addition to being susceptible to single-event effects (SEE) and total ionizing dose (TID) degradation, most NAND devices are subject to corrupted data naturally arising during normal operation conditions but are increased with radiation exposure. Because of this, NAND devices require error correction code (ECC) schemes even in terrestrial environments, without degradation due to radiation effects, with radiation effects reducing the overall lifespan of the device.

One obvious remedy is shielding. This always provides protection. However, one must consider what happens if the shields are destroyed, as in the case of a flight recorder. So, the best design practices involve designing if no shields are present. Another possible solution is the use of Rad Hardened devices, which incorporate internal radiation shields.


Summary of Radiation Testing That Has Been Preformed

Single-event effects and total ionizing-dose testing was performed on a NAND Flash device. Results are presented and the consequences for error correction architectures analyzed, taking into account the fact that even brand new flash devices could be susceptible to data corruption even with no external stress applied. The analysis indicates that many typical error correction architectures are not totally effective because of the variety of radiation effects that are possible.

TID and SEE testing for the flash NAND die used in the DDC 256 Gb (16-bit bus) and 192 Gb (24-bit bus) parts have been performed. Using the results of these tests, comparisons on the effectiveness of various ECC architectures in reducing the upset rate for the device are evident. This is only representative of what could happen and not intended to be totally encompassing.

Three modes were tested.



In the static test, the device was programmed, and the pattern was verified

immediately prior to irradiation. The DUT was powered on but

no reads or writes were performed during irradiation. The DUT

was irradiated to a fluence of 1Å~107 ion/cm2 and monitored for

single event latch-up (SEL) or single event functional interrupt

(SEFI). Following irradiation, the device was read again, and a

final erase-write-verify (EWV) performed to verify



Read Only:

During read-only testing, the device was programmed and

the pattern was verified immediately prior to irradiation. The

DUT was powered on and read continually during the test. The

log file recorded the number of blocks that were read during the

test. During irradiation the device was monitored to verify

functionality. Following a SEFI the beam was stopped, the

current was recorded, and an attempt was made to recover the

device, first through software intervention, and eventually by

cycling device power. Following irradiation, the device was

read again, and a final Erase-Write-Verify (EWV) was performed to verify




 For EWV testing, the DUT was powered on and a pattern was

continually erased, written, and verified to each block in the

device. The log file recorded the number of blocks that were

accessed during the test. During irradiation the device was

monitored to determine if a SEFI had occurred, and recovery

was attempted following beam termination.

Testing was performed on die, not on shielded packages.

 All modes displayed some bit errors resulting in incorrect data.


 Some Architectures Used to minimize Radiation Effects


A. Triple Mode Redundancy (TMR)

Rates for the failure of triple mode redundant (TMR) devices are based on the method using three 8 bit data buses, and a voter module that selects the best of three, These methods are especially pertinent for the use of  a device with a 24 bit data bus such as 69F192G24 device which has a 24 bit wide bus to facilitate a triplicated 8-bit wide architecture. Of course, three separate 8 bit devices can be used as well.



The single-error correct, double-error detect (SEC/DED) uses16 data-bits with 6 check-bits and is capable of correcting a single-bit error in a single address, or detecting a double bit

error in the same address location.

The method must be adjusted to accommodate the BCH architecture discussed in the next

section.  Error rate improvement beyond the MBU rate would require more robust error

correction architecture.



The BCH uses 13 bits of overhead correction for each bit of correction. Theoretically, any number of bits can be corrected so long as there is enough overhead area in the Flash Pages. That is not a problem in today’s Flash. 24 or more bit correction is common. Usually a CRC is used over the data and overhead area for preventing failure.



 It is also possible to use multiple layers of correction. For example, TMR and ECC codes.

In one instance, TMR die are voted prior to applying ECC. In another each die is separately subjected to ECC prior to TMR voting. In both cases, a system error will occur when there is a SEFI in two legs of the TMR. However, these architectures would be less vulnerable to SEFI+SEU failures that dominate the TMR only architecture. We note that the UE rate in the SEFI + SEU case for both architectures is the product of the SEFI rate and

the rate for the appropriate type of SEU.

With each of these architectures, periodic data scrubbing is included, which further enhances reliability.



NAND Flash devices are subject to data corruption even under terrestrial conditions. The data indicates that the error correction methods used in terrestrial application can be used to attain relatively low error rates even in the harsh environment of space. Determining NAND UE rate in space requires careful attention to the interplay of the baseline upset rates for multiple effects as well as architectural considerations such as ECC precedence and scrubbing rates. Because there are multiple SEE that need to be accounted for care must be taken to ensure that a specific error correction architecture is robust to all possible failure modes. As an example, the BCH ECC is robust in correcting bit errors, however it can be defeated by a single SEFI, and as a result, the UE for the system is limited by the SEFI rate. Thus SEFI must be considered in any NAND architecture application intended for space.


Please note that this research and article is for general information and was independently completed by Carmine Cupani of CTech Electronics, not by Delkin Engineers.



  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Related Posts

FAQs about Conformal Coating Benefits

  Solid state drives (SSDs) and memory cards are inevitably exposed to environmental conditions that...

Delkin Devices Technical Success Stories- Female Engineer- Businesswoman
Customer Success Stories: Evaluating NAND Storage Solutions in Embedded Memory Cards

  For customers shopping for industrial embedded storage solutions, comparing different SLC memory cards is...

Industrial Flash Storage Encryption and Security Features

 For industrial flash storage, data security encryption is a critical consideration. This kind of...

Embedded Systems for Power Applications

  When it comes to applications in the power industry, unreliability is simply not an...

Industrial Flash Storage for Ag Tech Applications

  The agricultural industry is the driving force behind one of the most critical pieces...

Frequently Asked Questions about Industrial USB

USB storage is one of the oldest and most recognizable forms of memory on...

Engineer Reviewing S.M.A.R.T Data
Customer Success Story: Finding the Link Between a Locked BOM, Speed, and Performance

  At Delkin, many of our customers tell us that one of the key features...

Understanding Embedded Memory Systems
Get the Facts about Embedded Memory Design

  Embedded memory drives technology for consumer, commercial, and industrial marketplaces. Virtually every bit of...

Delkin CFexpress
Answering Your Questions about Industrial CFexpress

  The challenge with today’s industrial devices is designing them to meet two competing demands:...

How to Find an Industrial Storage Supplier

Industrial storage suppliers are not all the same. While embedded memory is the norm...